The MOT Files

Known faults, from the test record

Mini Clubman common problems

What fails on the Mini Clubman at MOT, which parts are behind it, and how each model year compares. From 27,749 DVSA test records.

Data updated

Quick answer

The Mini Clubman's most common MOT problems are tyres, bulbs and lamps, coil springs, recorded in 49.7%, 27.4% and 15.0% of failed tests respectively. By model year, 2018 cars pass most often (82.4%) and 2016 cars least (77.2%), though most of that gap is age. Every figure here is what testers recorded, not what owners reported.

A “common problems” list is usually a forum thread: whoever had the worst day writes the longest post. This one is built the other way, from every Mini Clubman that took an MOT last year and what the tester wrote down. It cannot see breakdowns, electrical gremlins or a gearbox that hunts, because the test does not check those. What it can see, it sees across 27,749 cars.

By component

What wears out on a Clubman

Failure items grouped by the part behind them, with the share of failed Mini Clubman tests recording each. A part can carry several DVSA wordings; they are listed beneath. One failed test often lists several items, so shares do not sum to 100%.

  1. 1.Tyres

    49.7% of failed tests

    Tread wears with every mile and sidewalls age and take kerb damage; the legal minimum is 1.6 mm across the central three-quarters.

    • “A tyre seriously damaged” — explained15.4%
    • “Tyre tread depth not in accordance with the requirements” — explained12.9%
    • “A tyre cords visible or damaged” — explained7.6%
    • “A tyre seriously damaged” — explained7.0%

    Across all cars, tyres failures run at a similar rate at every age, because they are replaced on a cycle rather than wearing out with the car. How long tyres last

  2. 2.Bulbs and lamps

    27.4% of failed tests

    Filament bulbs simply expire; the cheapest and most avoidable failure on the test, and one of the most recorded.

    • “Stop lamp missing, inoperative or in the case of a multiple light source more than 1/2 not functioning” — explained16.5%
    • “A direction indicator lamp missing, inoperative or in the case of a multiple light source more than 1/2 not functioning” — explained4.4%
    • “A lamp missing, inoperative or in the case of a multiple light source more than 1/2 not functioning” — explained4.3%
    • “Headlamp levelling device inoperative” — explained0.9%

    Across all cars, bulbs and lamps failures climb 15-fold between three and fifteen years, peaking at 15+ years. How long bulbs and lamps last

  3. 3.Coil springs

    15.0% of failed tests

    Springs fatigue and corrode where the coating chips, then snap, often at the bottom coil; potholes and salt accelerate it.

    • “A spring or spring component fractured or seriously weakened” — explained15.0%

    Across all cars, coil springs failures climb 20-fold between three and fifteen years, peaking at 12–14 years. How long coil springs last

  4. 4.Wiper blades and washers

    12.7% of failed tests

    Rubber blades harden and split within a year or two; washer jets block and pumps fail.

    • “Wiper blade missing or obviously not clearing the windscreen” — explained7.5%
    • “Windscreen washers not working or not providing sufficient fluid to clear the windscreen” — explained3.7%
    • “Windscreen washers not working or not providing sufficient fluid to clear the windscreen” — explained1.6%

    Across all cars, wiper blades and washers failures run at a similar rate at every age, because they are replaced on a cycle rather than wearing out with the car. How long wiper blades and washers last

  5. 5.Brake pads and shoes

    10.8% of failed tests

    Friction material wears with use; the MOT limit is 1.5 mm and a pad that thin is close to metal on metal.

    • “a brake lining or pad worn below 1.5mm” — explained8.8%
    • “Brake lining or pad worn down to wear indicator” — explained2.1%

    Across all cars, brake pads and shoes failures run at a similar rate at every age, because they are replaced on a cycle rather than wearing out with the car. How long brake pads and shoes last

  6. 6.Suspension bushes

    7.2% of failed tests

    Rubber bushes in arms and links perish and split with age and load; the most recorded suspension item on the test.

    • “A suspension pin, bush or joint excessively worn” — explained5.1%
    • “A suspension joint dust cover missing or no longer prevents the ingress of dirt etc” — explained1.1%
    • “A suspension pin, bush or joint excessively worn” — explained1.0%

    Across all cars, suspension bushes failures climb 20-fold between three and fifteen years, peaking at 15+ years. How long suspension bushes last

  7. 7.Headlamp aim

    3.9% of failed tests

    Aim drifts with sagging suspension, a knocked lamp or a botched bulb change; adjustment, not a part.

    • “The aim of a headlamp is not within limits laid down in the requirements” — explained1.5%
    • “The aim of a headlamp is not within limits laid down in the requirements” — explained1.5%
    • “The aim of a headlamp is not within limits laid down in the requirements” — explained0.9%

  8. 8.Engine management

    3.6% of failed tests

    The MIL lamp lit is a failure in itself, whatever the stored code; the fault codes section explains what lies behind it.

    • “Engine MIL illuminated indicating a malfunction” — explained2.6%
    • “Engine MIL illuminated indicating a malfunction” — explained1.0%

By registration year

Clubman problems by year

MOT pass rate for Mini Clubman cars by the year they were first registered, from years with at least 1,000 tests. Every car in a row is the same age, so the rate is raw. Neighbouring years differ by a year of wear — a step of a point or two is age. No single step here is large enough to point at a generation change.

201577%
201677%−0.3
201780%+2.8
201882%+2.4

Last column: change on the previous year, in points. Years registered within the last three years have not yet been tested and are not shown.

Before it fails

What testers warn Clubman owners about

Advisories are the same parts a year or two earlier. Share of all Mini Clubman tests carrying an advisory for each.

Go deeper

The rest of the Clubman file

Common questions

What are the most common problems with a Mini Clubman?
Going by what fails the MOT, tyres (recorded in 49.7% of failed tests), bulbs and lamps (recorded in 27.4% of failed tests), and coil springs (recorded in 15.0% of failed tests). These are the items testers actually record across 27,749 tests, not reports from owners, so they describe what goes wrong at the point where it has to be fixed.
Which Mini Clubman year is the most reliable?
By MOT pass rate, Mini Clubman cars registered in 2018 do best at 82.4% and 2016 cars do worst at 77.2%. Most of that ordering is simply age — newer cars pass more — so read the year table for steps larger than a couple of points between neighbouring years; those mark a change in the cars rather than the calendar.
Is the Mini Clubman reliable?
Adjusted for the age and mileage of the cars tested, the Mini Clubman passes 76.8% of MOTs against a national 72.3%. An MOT measures roadworthiness on the day rather than breakdowns or running costs, so this is a reliability measure in the narrow sense: how often the car meets the legal standard, and what stops it.
What should I check when buying a used Mini Clubman?
Start with what fails most: tyres, bulbs and lamps, coil springs. Then read the car's own MOT history for advisories carried year to year without repair — the model tells you what to expect, the history tells you whether this owner dealt with it.

Analysis built from DVSA data of